American Idol 'American Idol' judges Harry Connick Jr. and Keith Urban clash over finalists 03/20/2014 American Idol judges Harry Connick Jr. and Keith Urban simply weren't seeing eye to eye during Wednesday night's broadcast on Fox. Read More RELATED NEWS Former 'American Idol' finalist Sam Woolf releases his first album'American Idol' adds Scott Borchetta as new mentor to replace Randy Jackson 'American Idol' to premiere January 7 on Fox with schedule changes throughout Season 14 TAGS: American Idol Harry Connick Jr. Jennifer Lopez Ryan Seacrest Keith Urban