American Idol Harry Connick Jr.: I don't know if I'd be a good 'American Idol' judge 05/06/2010 Harry Connick Jr. is downplaying recent talk that he'd be a good choice to replace departing American Idol judge Simon Cowell on the show's judging panel next year. Read More RELATED NEWS Kelly Clarkson reunites original 'American Idol' judges Simon Cowell, Paula Abdul and Randy Jackson'American Idol' was "one of the worst decisions I've ever made," says former judge Ellen DeGeneresCrystal Bowersox and husband Brian Walker announce divorce TAGS: American Idol The X Factor Harry Connick Jr. Simon Cowell Ryan Seacrest Shania Twain