American Idol Marc Anthony: Jennifer Lopez split was a mutual decision 09/02/2011 Marc Anthony says his split from ex-wife and American Idol judge Jennifer Lopez was a mutual decision, despite reports alleging otherwise. Read More RELATED NEWS 'American Idol' runner-up Lauren Alaina calls off engagement to high school sweetheart Alex Hopkins'American Idol' winner Scotty McCreery marries Gabi DugalScotty McCreery: I forgot there was a gun in the backpack I took to airport TAGS: American Idol Jennifer Lopez Jada Pinkett Smith Marc Anthony Will Smith