The Bachelor 'The Bachelor' alum Cassie Randolph reveals the "horrible" way she learned Colton Underwood is gay 03/24/2022 The Bachelor alum Cassie Randolph has revealed the "horrible" way in which she found out her now ex-boyfriend Colton Underwood is gay. Read More RELATED NEWS 'The Bachelor' alum Cassie Randolph is engaged to musician Brighton Reinhardt'The Bachelor' alum Colton Underwood and husband welcome first child'The Bachelor' alum Sydney Lotuaco welcomes first child with husband Nick Wehby TAGS: Bachelor in Paradise The Bachelor Tayshia Adams Tia Booth Kaitlyn Bristowe Clayton Echard Susie Evans Hannah Godwin Becca Kufrin, Cassie Randolph Colton Underwood The Bachelor The First Time